Friday saw HSBC and DBS join the ranks of banks raising the interest rate on new mortgages. The new benchmark for HIBOR linked mortgages is now around HIBOR plus 1.75 per cent, making the effective interest rate 1.95 per cent.
Funding pressures have been blamed for the increase - apparently banks are having difficulty in attracting deposits. Given that I have seen zero evidence of deposit rates increasing and the banking industry is still showing a healthy loan to deposit ratio, this explanation is, at best, somewhat hard to accept.
In any event the rates have gone up but:
1. The increase has no bearing on existing loans - HIBOR itself has not changed
2. Borrowing is still cheap. With inflation (as measured by CPI) still well above 3 per cent, the real cost of funding is still negative
3. The availability of funding is a greater constraint on investing than the price paid for debt - banks are using valuations which are generally below market and require both high deposits and a healthy margin of safety when evaluating borrowers' ability to repay
4. The increase in borrowing costs will help improve banks' NIM, but given that the increase will only apply to new loans, it will be a while before there is a meaningful impact on bank profits
5. There will be no impact for the well heeled cash buyers who make up a sizable part of the market.
The bottom line is that the interest rate increase is unlikely to have much impact in and of itself. Of greater significance is the question of whether this is the beginning of both a trend of rising interest rates and other measures which will make property less attractive as an investment asset class. With the former, events in the US will have as much, if not more,impact than local events. As to the latter, the biggest issue is the government controlled supply of land, with other government initiatives such as increased stamp duty and the continued demand from PRC investors.
So far, I see no reason to change my strategy of holding my properties for the longer term. The incentive for not paying off mortgages early just got stronger.
Saturday, April 16, 2011
Thursday, April 14, 2011
Positive credit sharing
Hong Kong has finally adopted a regime allowing banks to share positive credit data - essentially the details of each loan or credit facility taken out.
Historically, banks were limited to providing negative credit data to the credit agency which meant that they had difficulty in verifying the true amount of existing indebtedness of loan applicants. The sharing of positive credit will (supposedly) allow banks to make better credit decisions. Also by making it harder for people to lie about their finances, the risk of default should go down which means that the cost of borrowing should be lower.
While the first argument has merit, it is puzzling that the initial submissions of positive credit data require the affirmative consent of the data subjects (borrowers). In effect, there is no compulsion to agree to disclosure at this stage. Given the duration of the average mortgage loan, this makes the entire exercise somewhat flawed. Going forward, presumably loans will granted only on the basis that the borrower consents to sharing of positive credit data.
The second argument has either limited or no merit. Interest rates are unlikely to go much lower. What is more likely is that the banks will use the data to start charging higher interest rates to borrowers perceived as being less credit worthy.
For my part, I have decided to consent to sharing of my credit data. Firstly, I have nothing to hide as full disclosure was made each time I took out a loan. Secondly, it is possible that failure to disclose will make obtaining future finance either more difficult or more expensive.
As to the process, the banks must have really tried hard to make it as difficult as possible:
1. the consent form does not state any information about the borrower or the loan. I had to fill all that in myself;
2. each loan requires a separate consent;
3. there was no free post envelope;
4. where loans were made to companies, the consent from the company was required but not from the guarantor.
Points 1 and 2 are matters of inconvenience - and an invitation for errors and omissions to create more work for everyone. Point 3 was dealt with by dropping the completed froms in the cheque deposit box at the bank on the way to lunch. Point 4 is clearly a mistake and creates a presumption that information about guarantors will not be included in the data base (which seems wrong).
Historically, banks were limited to providing negative credit data to the credit agency which meant that they had difficulty in verifying the true amount of existing indebtedness of loan applicants. The sharing of positive credit will (supposedly) allow banks to make better credit decisions. Also by making it harder for people to lie about their finances, the risk of default should go down which means that the cost of borrowing should be lower.
While the first argument has merit, it is puzzling that the initial submissions of positive credit data require the affirmative consent of the data subjects (borrowers). In effect, there is no compulsion to agree to disclosure at this stage. Given the duration of the average mortgage loan, this makes the entire exercise somewhat flawed. Going forward, presumably loans will granted only on the basis that the borrower consents to sharing of positive credit data.
The second argument has either limited or no merit. Interest rates are unlikely to go much lower. What is more likely is that the banks will use the data to start charging higher interest rates to borrowers perceived as being less credit worthy.
For my part, I have decided to consent to sharing of my credit data. Firstly, I have nothing to hide as full disclosure was made each time I took out a loan. Secondly, it is possible that failure to disclose will make obtaining future finance either more difficult or more expensive.
As to the process, the banks must have really tried hard to make it as difficult as possible:
1. the consent form does not state any information about the borrower or the loan. I had to fill all that in myself;
2. each loan requires a separate consent;
3. there was no free post envelope;
4. where loans were made to companies, the consent from the company was required but not from the guarantor.
Points 1 and 2 are matters of inconvenience - and an invitation for errors and omissions to create more work for everyone. Point 3 was dealt with by dropping the completed froms in the cheque deposit box at the bank on the way to lunch. Point 4 is clearly a mistake and creates a presumption that information about guarantors will not be included in the data base (which seems wrong).
Thursday, April 07, 2011
Xtep purchased #2
This morning I doubled my investment in Xtep (HK:1368) paying HK$5.42 per share. The reasons for purchasing are essentially the same as they were in mid March when I made my original purchase at HK$4.94 . Since then the company has reported its results for 2010 (excellent) which included an increase in dividend. My average purchase price is HK$5.17 (including costs).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)